Brain Teasers
The Old Monk and the Staircase
Fun: (3.01)
Difficulty: (2.49)
Puzzle ID: #33274
Submitted By: OldChinaHand Corrected By: Winner4600
Submitted By: OldChinaHand Corrected By: Winner4600
Trivia
Trivia brain teasers have some element of trivia in them, but they are not just pure trivia questions.Trivia
Construction of a stronger and more massive bell tower for the monastery to replace the one destroyed during the last civil strife with a neighboring lord was well underway when the old Monk visited the site. The Abbot showed the Monk the drawings and model for the three-bell tower. The Monk was impressed until he stood where the bell chamber would be and saw the spiral staircase in this medieval bell tower running the wrong direction (counterclockwise).
"The staircase direction must be changed," said the Old Monk. The Abbot looked at the staircase and agreed. Why?
"The staircase direction must be changed," said the Old Monk. The Abbot looked at the staircase and agreed. Why?
Hint
Left-handed people, it was assumed, were descendants of the devil.Answer
Spiral staircases in medieval castles, towers and Keeps were run clockwise. This is because all knights used to be right-handed. When the intruding army would climb the stairs they would not be able to use their right hand, which was holding the sword because of the difficulties of climbing the stairs, giving clear advantage to the defenders. Many of the orders of clergy had military training in order to defend monasteries and Abbeys during the middle ages.Left-handed knights would have had no troubles, except left-handed people could never become knights because it was assumed that they were descendants of the devil.
Hide Hint Show Hint Hide Answer Show Answer
What Next?
View a Similar Brain Teaser...
If you become a registered user you can vote on this brain teaser, keep track of which ones you have seen, and even make your own.
Solve a Puzzle
Comments
That is quite interesting, China! Thank you!
That's way cool! great job!
Well, I was wondering whether my solution was right and it was... I wasn't so sure since most monks did not have military training. In fact only some fraternities , like the templars, the Teutonic Order, were allowed to be members of the clergy and propagate the Christianism with the sword...!
Well, I knew it was thought improper to write with one's left hand, but I didn't know it was that weird. Though I wonder why it is considered good manners to eat with your left? Hmm perhaps you could use that next time! Great Job!
My old boss, who was born in 1911, was left handed, and he said that even that late he was being hit for writing left-handed! Really makes you wonder. They must have HATED Polar Bears!
I like that one!?!?!? Did you know that Ben Franklin one of important people of the AMerican revolution was left handed??? My brother is also left handed and so are some of my best friends!?!?1 i can't imagine them being hit!?!?!
Clockwise going up or down?
Very Interesting...... and I learned something to boot.
Good one! I'm left handed... Boodler - what's the story about polar bears???
Your boss was old indeed, Boodle! If he was born in 1911, that would make him 95 today!
My father was born in '42 and was forced to write with his right hand. It hasn't been that long since the practice of forcing lefties to switch wasn't widespread. It still happens - I knew someone who is now around 25 who was forced by her grandmother.
Anyway, interesting teaser. For anyone further interested, try reading up on the Kerr family from Scotland and especially the castle Ferniehirst.
Anyway, interesting teaser. For anyone further interested, try reading up on the Kerr family from Scotland and especially the castle Ferniehirst.
YOU JOGGED MY MEMORY, IN MY RIGHT-MIND.
LEFT HANDERS, HAVE A DISPROPORTIONATE NUMBER OF GENIUS'
LEFT HANDERS, HAVE A DISPROPORTIONATE NUMBER OF GENIUS'
I remembered that factoid about the stairs after I read the answer. IMURRAY is right about one thing: Left handed people are the only ones in their right minds.
This is a very interesting bit of history that I wasn't aware of. I believe in the more recent years parents or grandparents try to "make" youngsters use their right hand because most things in this modern world are geared for right handers. Think about it. Try cutting a piece of paper with a pair of scissors using your left hand.
This teaser left me right perplexed. I did guess the Monk's name though. It is Costello.
I got this right away, but I practice with a sword and knew the history of those types of staircases.
And actually, many monks were actually former soldiers who went on to a life of monasticism. Though they were forbidden from shedding blood (via a sword) that didn't stop them from using a club or mace, which was seen as a non blood-letting weapon at the time. Plus many monasteries had armed guards/men-at-arms to protect them.
And actually, many monks were actually former soldiers who went on to a life of monasticism. Though they were forbidden from shedding blood (via a sword) that didn't stop them from using a club or mace, which was seen as a non blood-letting weapon at the time. Plus many monasteries had armed guards/men-at-arms to protect them.
This is an old fact, which has been around for ages! Very impressive teaser, China. This should get many responses from ALL walks of life. WTG
This is very intriguing, I must say; though, I am a wee bit surprised I didn't hear about this tidbit while studying in Scotland.
Whew--Those lefthanded devil worshippers!! I didn't see this coming!
This is really cool. I guess I would never be a knight.
Oh, and people say it's so much harder for lefties to do things like cutting paper and stuff, but we get used to it as we get older. I do most things with my right hand now except eat and right, and instinctively I use my left hand to grab things and pick up things. I love being a lefty, though! It's fun being different!
Oh, and people say it's so much harder for lefties to do things like cutting paper and stuff, but we get used to it as we get older. I do most things with my right hand now except eat and right, and instinctively I use my left hand to grab things and pick up things. I love being a lefty, though! It's fun being different!
I meant eat and *write*. I guess I was caught up in the left-right thing.
Very interesting. I had absolutely no idea. Great little tidbit there.
Interestingly enough, I have a brother (in his early 30's) who would have been a lefty except my parents wouldn't allow it. They didn't think it was devilish or anything foolish like that, but they did think it awkward and inhibiting, so they simply wouldn't allow it. They didn't hit him or anything, but they did constantly "correct" him and force him to eat and write with his right hand. It didn't hurt him to be forced to use his right hand. In fact, he's quite pleased with it now. He has some of the nicest handwritting I've seen, and is quite artistic, all with his right hand even though that wasn't his natural inclination. A little practice with the left and he could easily be ambidextrous. Of course, he still uses his left hand instinctively for certain things but is quite comfortable as an "unnatural" righty.
Anyhew, don't know why I shared that, but it just popped in my head
Interestingly enough, I have a brother (in his early 30's) who would have been a lefty except my parents wouldn't allow it. They didn't think it was devilish or anything foolish like that, but they did think it awkward and inhibiting, so they simply wouldn't allow it. They didn't hit him or anything, but they did constantly "correct" him and force him to eat and write with his right hand. It didn't hurt him to be forced to use his right hand. In fact, he's quite pleased with it now. He has some of the nicest handwritting I've seen, and is quite artistic, all with his right hand even though that wasn't his natural inclination. A little practice with the left and he could easily be ambidextrous. Of course, he still uses his left hand instinctively for certain things but is quite comfortable as an "unnatural" righty.
Anyhew, don't know why I shared that, but it just popped in my head
I say we get back to the brain teasers and leave the bits of information to another sight.
*site* must have gotten caught up in the left-right thing
hum......very interesting.....i actually remember that....wow.....goood one
Very interesting. It explains alot. My ex-husband is a lefty.
Why is it more difficult for a righty (carrying a sword) to climb a clockwise staircase vs. a counterclockwise one?
Interesting and educational - but I don't think it qualifies as a brain teaser. Really required a detailed knowledge of history to figure it out, not logic.
Very cute. Once I read the hint I got it. I did not know that they thought that left-handed people were decendants of the devil! That is really interesting!
Peanut: The story with polar bears is that it has been proven that all polar bears are left-handed.
Interesting isn't it???
Peanut: The story with polar bears is that it has been proven that all polar bears are left-handed.
Interesting isn't it???
I'm neather left nor right handed...I use both evenly. I prefer my left hand, but wasn't allowed to use it in school. And that was only 10 years ago.
nice!
I'm left handed (27 years old) and my kindergarten teacher tried to make me write with my right hand. Needless to say my parents had a couple of "choice" words for her when they talked to her about what happened.
--Unfortunately left-handers also have a shorter life-span, due to living in a right-handed world!--
I've heard this somewhere before...maybe someone can let me know if this is true.
--Unfortunately left-handers also have a shorter life-span, due to living in a right-handed world!--
I've heard this somewhere before...maybe someone can let me know if this is true.
Oh man!!! China, that was AMAZING!!! I LOVE learning about stuff like this!!! Gosh, I can't believe how, well,... jovial you've just made me!!! Thank you so much!!! Pleasepleaseplease submit more knight/monk/(I don't know how I want to classify this stuff) related trivia!
......(goin' right into my favorites)!
That is very intersting I never new that. It is true you learn something new every day.
Okay, I had a question about it, but I was thinking of a staircase spiralling up along the outer wall rather than a spiral staircase around a central pillar.
Cool trivia!
Cool trivia!
Good one, OCH, and a bit of historical trivia that I didn't know! Thanks for submitting!
Nov 07, 2006
Docfriday, Imagine if you will toting a 20 lb. sword up a narrow spiral staircase, i'm sure you have seen the common style of these, suspended from a pole which runs up the center. Now, while ascending in a clockwise direction you try to swing your sword with your right hand. I am sure that you can imagine that the pole which is on your right side is going to prove to be an obstacle when attempting a sweeping stroke, as will the stairs above your head when attempting an overhand stroke. Now picture an armored Knight, charging down the stairs at you with his sword hand hanging over the railing to his right, free to swing in any direction he so chooses. Unless you have one heck of a backhand swing, your future is looking pretty dim.
Thanks all for the feedback. I glad this teaser informed some and got others sharing their thoughts and experiences.
It still amazes me how just powerful social customs and manners can be and how much we are influenced by them. Thanks again. OCH
It still amazes me how just powerful social customs and manners can be and how much we are influenced by them. Thanks again. OCH
Excellent info there China. I enjoyed it very much. And of course I had no idea, but thank you.
I changed my son from left to right hand before he started school. I was later told that is part of why he never crawled and had poor eye hand coordination. Who knew?
I changed my son from left to right hand before he started school. I was later told that is part of why he never crawled and had poor eye hand coordination. Who knew?
uhhhhh.... I don't think this counts as a brain teaser. More like a fact question.
It astounds me that anyone EVER tried to persuade a left-handed person into being right-handec! How can anyone be so STUPID?
interesting information Thanks
THIS ONE IS A REPEAT ALMOST EXACTALLY OF ONE ALREADY HERE
I TRIED TO LOOK BACK FOR THE OTHER BUT I COULDN'T FIND IT, CAN SOMEONE PLEASE REPORT THIS TO BRAINGLE, I DON'T KNOW HOW TO
IF ANYONE COULD PLEASE SEARCH FOR THE OTHER, I MIGHT HAVE CHOSEN RANDOM OR IT IS IN THE 1ST 4 PAGES OF "TRICK"
IF YOU FIND THE OTHER PLEASE SEND ME A MESSAGE SO I CAN STOP SEARCHING, I HAVE BEEN SEARCHING FOR 1/2 HOUR SO FAR
THANK YOU
MURF.Q
I WOULD LIKE TO TELL YOU SOME INFORMATION, I AM A GENERAL PRACTICIONER, GP
MOST PEOPLE ARE WELL, OBVIOUSLY, BORN RIGHT HANDED. I AM ALSO RIGHT HANDED, BUT FOR SPORTS LIKE HOCKEY I USE MY LEFT HAND AS THE DOMINENT POSITION. THIS IS NOT UNUSUAL AT ALL.
I WOULD LIKE TO TELL YOU SOME INFORMATION, I AM A GENERAL PRACTICIONER, GP
MOST PEOPLE ARE WELL, OBVIOUSLY, BORN RIGHT HANDED. I AM ALSO RIGHT HANDED, BUT FOR SPORTS LIKE HOCKEY I USE MY LEFT HAND AS THE DOMINENT POSITION. THIS IS NOT UNUSUAL AT ALL.
What's wrong with the left hand?
Only 13 percent of people are left-handed so that must be why they thought it something to do with the Devel but they didn't know that the Devel isn't real.
You forgot one thing... the attackers won't be knights, and they may be all left-handed.
Hmmm......
i think i learned some medivel things today...good one
i think i learned some medivel things today...good one
Awesome trivia! And well-written teaser too. I love medieval stuff, and I'm adding this to my faves. I should've realized how handedness would've decided this! I guessed pure superstition, but was too curious about the answer to think about it longer.
To Jimbo, though he commented over a month ago: it's clockwise going down. They were standing in the bell tower. (I wondered this too, and for half a moment I thought there was ambiguity, but then realized where they were standing.)
To the nay-sayer who claimed this wasn't a teaser, take a look at the category. What else would a trivia teaser entail, except a fact question?
To Jimbo, though he commented over a month ago: it's clockwise going down. They were standing in the bell tower. (I wondered this too, and for half a moment I thought there was ambiguity, but then realized where they were standing.)
To the nay-sayer who claimed this wasn't a teaser, take a look at the category. What else would a trivia teaser entail, except a fact question?
vey intresting teaser great job and well thought out
Interesting...guess I never would've made it as a knight! Fun!
I went to school and was taught by nuns. Some of them tried to change my writing hand to right,but I always managed to go back to me left. In almost everything I am ambidexterous. I guess there are even fewer of us than lefties. And the teaser was very interesting, but I didn't know the answer.
I didn't know that!!!
I guess the one in the puzzle is clockwise going down and counterclockwise going up. Depending on the big the distance is between the center of the midpoint of the spiral and the closest point on the staircase, that could make it easier for right-handed people to descend than to ascend.
Yes, very interesting, but this is a teaser and we are supposed to know this why????
The practice of "correcting" a left handed person still exists. Several friends of mine are left handed and one in particular was telling me that when she was in Kindergarten they would try to make her use her right hand, but when they saw how stressful it was on her, they decided to leave it be.
She and the other leftys I know (including my hubby) are all able to do anything that they need to with ease. Though places like the "Leftorium" don't exist, many products including left handed scissors and coputer mice do. Most of them have just learned to adapt and can use their right hands to do a lot of things.
There are many things in society that can be historically traced to most ppl being right handed.
Mounting a horse for instance. As knights were right-handed a sword is word on the left hip, so they can grab it with their right hand. They would mount the horse from the left so that the sword was not in the way. Though we don't see many ppl walking around with swords any more the practice continues.
A wrist watch was worn on your left wrist not only so it didn't get in the way, but more importantly so you could wind it (yes young'uns you used to have to wind a watch at least once a day or it wouldn't run).
The closures on men's and women's clothing are on opposite sides so that the man can use his right hand to do up the zipper/buttons/snaps while a noble or aristocratic woman would not dress herself, so the buttons were put on so her lady-in-waiting was able to use her right hand to fasten the clothing.
She and the other leftys I know (including my hubby) are all able to do anything that they need to with ease. Though places like the "Leftorium" don't exist, many products including left handed scissors and coputer mice do. Most of them have just learned to adapt and can use their right hands to do a lot of things.
There are many things in society that can be historically traced to most ppl being right handed.
Mounting a horse for instance. As knights were right-handed a sword is word on the left hip, so they can grab it with their right hand. They would mount the horse from the left so that the sword was not in the way. Though we don't see many ppl walking around with swords any more the practice continues.
A wrist watch was worn on your left wrist not only so it didn't get in the way, but more importantly so you could wind it (yes young'uns you used to have to wind a watch at least once a day or it wouldn't run).
The closures on men's and women's clothing are on opposite sides so that the man can use his right hand to do up the zipper/buttons/snaps while a noble or aristocratic woman would not dress herself, so the buttons were put on so her lady-in-waiting was able to use her right hand to fasten the clothing.
Completely clueless. Great teaser. My dearest friends whole family are lefties.
Very interesting! It seems completely relevant to strengthen our brains by unusual facts. Thank you!
Never would have guessed. I'm a right-hander, but I taught myself to be ambidextrous.
This is more of a trivia thing than a teaser. It was interesting and we learned something, which we will probably never use, but shouldn't it be in the trivia section?
Just curious and wondering.
Just curious and wondering.
Hmmm, learn something new everyday. I don't know if I will ever need or use it, but I learned something.
Fun and entertaining teaser. I got the answer "Clockwise" correct but had no idea of why that had to be. Excellent answer description given.
Alas, this theory, while frequently stated, is probably not true. The more likely explanation about staircase direction is that someone descending can put their right hand on the outer wall for balance.
A significant minority of medieval castles have stairways going the other way. One example is Norwich Castle, which William the Conqueror built soon after the conquest of England to hold down the (then) large and potentially rebellious town of Norwich.
It has to be said that since there are no records of the builders reasons we can't rule out the theory, but at best it's a guess.
A significant minority of medieval castles have stairways going the other way. One example is Norwich Castle, which William the Conqueror built soon after the conquest of England to hold down the (then) large and potentially rebellious town of Norwich.
It has to be said that since there are no records of the builders reasons we can't rule out the theory, but at best it's a guess.
To post a comment, please create an account and sign in.
Follow Braingle!