The Werewolf Game
Game #3240: Bad Eggs
This private game is moderated by bbgrl. Please read the rules and contact the moderator with any questions or concerns about this game.
This game finished in 6 rounds.
The golden egg is still out there guys. Along with 2 Rottens.
---This message was edited on 2017-04-09 07:59:39---
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
---This message was edited on 2017-04-09 07:59:39---
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
Unexpected eating again.....will have to check jayos comments , spv for now
It would seem bradon was the one he singled out as a wolf, so the wolves who should be seer hunting at all coats certainly could have picked out that, I still see no reaason for bradon to vote who in round 1 though, not only is it bad tactics it's a bit provocative and antogonistic to busy our partner that early for little reason....
Will have to think about this
Cats suspect list seemed completely and totally random, brin at the top
So disn't seem very genuine
---This message was edited on 2017-04-09 07:29:45---
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
It would seem bradon was the one he singled out as a wolf, so the wolves who should be seer hunting at all coats certainly could have picked out that, I still see no reaason for bradon to vote who in round 1 though, not only is it bad tactics it's a bit provocative and antogonistic to busy our partner that early for little reason....
Will have to think about this
Cats suspect list seemed completely and totally random, brin at the top
So disn't seem very genuine
---This message was edited on 2017-04-09 07:29:45---
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
It would help if you gave me a good sales pitch bradon, jayo being eaten after having a funny fesling about you is hard to ignore
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
Very true, although smart wolves may be trying to frame Bobby. I will wait to place a vote. I would like to hear what others think before making a decision. I'm also trveling today, so I won't be back on until evening. I will vote then. Bobby, speak up - I want to hear your thoughts on Jayo's eating.
Take all sorrow out of life and you take away all richness, and depth, and tenderness. The capacity of sorrow belongs to our grandeur. It is the furnace that melts hearts together in love.
Take all sorrow out of life and you take away all richness, and depth, and tenderness. The capacity of sorrow belongs to our grandeur. It is the furnace that melts hearts together in love.
If you two actually think If I were a wolf I would immediately vote to eat someone who said he had "just a mild suspicion and nothing I'd call concrete " and then place his vote for someone else and leave it there, then I guess there is nothing I can say that will change your minds. I already stated I'm definitely not rotten and I hoped the Seer has checked that out. If not yet, please do so.
Snowy, you have been awfully quiet this game, so has Deb. Which one of you is the rotten egg?
We still have our Seer, sure would be nice if you could confirm, but if you chose to look elsewhere, so be it.
For now, I think I was wrong in not going with Brin's usually good instincts and vote Sophie, so I'll do that now.
Formula for success: rise early, work hard, strike oil. J. Paul Getty
Snowy, you have been awfully quiet this game, so has Deb. Which one of you is the rotten egg?
We still have our Seer, sure would be nice if you could confirm, but if you chose to look elsewhere, so be it.
For now, I think I was wrong in not going with Brin's usually good instincts and vote Sophie, so I'll do that now.
Formula for success: rise early, work hard, strike oil. J. Paul Getty
But he also said this
Bradon - The last time I had a funny feeling about her I was on the right track and I just have that feeling again. Her posts in the lead up to Who being shot aren't exactly giving me good (egg) vibrations. Leaning wolf
There's a massive difference between not eating someone who mildly suspects you in Round 1 and 2, and who has 'funny feelings' about you in Round 3. You wouldn't eat him if there was no seer, but there IS a seer, wolves MUST eat or at least strongly consider eating players who say things like this about wolves.
If the wolves ate Jayo to frame you, the wolves made a terrible blunder.
If they ate Jayo because they thought he was a seer candidate, and you are not a wolf, Jayo said something else that seemed a little prescient too them.
The "I wouldnt eat" argument is unconvincing here, but your round 1 actions still carry a lot of weight. Neither of us have voted or indicated we will so it's a little unfair to dismiss our (quite fair position) by saying that 'nothing will change our mind'
---This message was edited on 2017-04-09 10:25:44---
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
Bradon - The last time I had a funny feeling about her I was on the right track and I just have that feeling again. Her posts in the lead up to Who being shot aren't exactly giving me good (egg) vibrations. Leaning wolf
There's a massive difference between not eating someone who mildly suspects you in Round 1 and 2, and who has 'funny feelings' about you in Round 3. You wouldn't eat him if there was no seer, but there IS a seer, wolves MUST eat or at least strongly consider eating players who say things like this about wolves.
If the wolves ate Jayo to frame you, the wolves made a terrible blunder.
If they ate Jayo because they thought he was a seer candidate, and you are not a wolf, Jayo said something else that seemed a little prescient too them.
The "I wouldnt eat" argument is unconvincing here, but your round 1 actions still carry a lot of weight. Neither of us have voted or indicated we will so it's a little unfair to dismiss our (quite fair position) by saying that 'nothing will change our mind'
---This message was edited on 2017-04-09 10:25:44---
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
Kati seemed like the seer last round. Thankfully he's not. But his list must have been close enough to fool the fireballs. Or right on a few points. Or ...
Bradon catches my eye for now.
---This message was edited on 2017-04-09 10:33:04---
"I discovered I scream the same whether I'm about to be devoured by a Great White or if a piece of seaweed touches my foot." Axl Rose
Bradon catches my eye for now.
---This message was edited on 2017-04-09 10:33:04---
"I discovered I scream the same whether I'm about to be devoured by a Great White or if a piece of seaweed touches my foot." Axl Rose
Im assuming 'Kati" is just a keyboard shift of Jayo
Im most suspicious of Cat for his suspect list (which just seems totally random) and Deb....for no real strong reasons :/
If Bradon is human, I could see cat as someone disregarding a seer hunt in his eating...I guess
---This message was edited on 2017-04-09 10:38:41---
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
Im most suspicious of Cat for his suspect list (which just seems totally random) and Deb....for no real strong reasons :/
If Bradon is human, I could see cat as someone disregarding a seer hunt in his eating...I guess
---This message was edited on 2017-04-09 10:38:41---
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
The_Spider wrote:
If the wolves ate Jayo to frame you, the wolves made a terrible blunder.
If they ate Jayo because they thought he was a seer candidate, and you are not a wolf, Jayo said something else that seemed a little prescient too them.'
Jayo also wrote:
"Sophie - Hopefully the Seer has divined her, I am not confident to get a decent read on her game but will keep her in mind"
I would have to agree with you, the wolves made a terrible blunder, and you know very well if I were a wolf, I never would have eaten Jayo, at least not immediately after he said what he said. I'm really not that stupid.
Formula for success: rise early, work hard, strike oil. J. Paul Getty
If the wolves ate Jayo to frame you, the wolves made a terrible blunder.
If they ate Jayo because they thought he was a seer candidate, and you are not a wolf, Jayo said something else that seemed a little prescient too them.'
Jayo also wrote:
"Sophie - Hopefully the Seer has divined her, I am not confident to get a decent read on her game but will keep her in mind"
I would have to agree with you, the wolves made a terrible blunder, and you know very well if I were a wolf, I never would have eaten Jayo, at least not immediately after he said what he said. I'm really not that stupid.
Formula for success: rise early, work hard, strike oil. J. Paul Getty
Yes, but its common for a seer to mention "the seer" in order to obfuscate.
Im actually not inclined to suspect you as strongly as I should be at this juncture (gonna wait to hear from everyone), but I totally disagree with you about the Jayo eating. Wolves HAVE to find and kill the seer at all costs. If (hypothetically) you thought Jayo was the seer, you would almost certainly have to eat him (and this doesnt rule out your partner eating him on your behalf). This argument comes up a lot, and its a good argument very early or when the seer is dead. It is not a good argument in Night 3 and 4, when the seer hunt is at it's most critical. It's an important distinction.
Heading out for a bit, might post a Deb List later
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
Im actually not inclined to suspect you as strongly as I should be at this juncture (gonna wait to hear from everyone), but I totally disagree with you about the Jayo eating. Wolves HAVE to find and kill the seer at all costs. If (hypothetically) you thought Jayo was the seer, you would almost certainly have to eat him (and this doesnt rule out your partner eating him on your behalf). This argument comes up a lot, and its a good argument very early or when the seer is dead. It is not a good argument in Night 3 and 4, when the seer hunt is at it's most critical. It's an important distinction.
Heading out for a bit, might post a Deb List later
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
I agree that putting Brin[me] at the top of a list of wolves would be suspect for sure, but if you look at Cat's list Spider, you'll see he merely listed everyone but himself in alphabetical order. I think he was attempting a joke. That said. I haven't changed my mind about Sophie. She really didn't deny being a wolf or make a case for herself. She merely said, she's wrong about me.
Your love gave me memories too beautiful to forget.
Add - I guess we can clear Brin though as a wolf because she was right about Who. Even if she is wrong about me. I'm going to put an spv in for Cab because I have no clue and she has no votes.
Your love gave me memories too beautiful to forget.
Could be an easy frame job I guess
SPV until I can have more time to think on the game
I never make mitsakes
SPV until I can have more time to think on the game
I never make mitsakes
oh yes you are right about Cat's list
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
Morning
I will make my deb's list from memory because I can't copy and paste
Bobi-i am all over the place with her. Says she is not rotten, I want to believe that, but what the sticking point for me is, is she wants the seer to divine her. If you are a good egg why would you want the seer to waste a divine? But then again is it a ploy to make the seer dismiss her as a rotten possibility?? I need some clarification on that.
Brin-I made a comment last game that she has good insights and I was missing them(she was a wolf) has she adapted and that is the reason for her Sophie fixation???
Cat- I never have a clue, you really need to be more of a chatty catty!!
Cab- I can't get a read on her this game, is she being quieter than normal??
Sophie- other than brin's gut I don't see anything, because dan's reasoning does sound sound
Dan- if Sophie is rotten then dan could very well be rotten. His points make sense, coherent and able to follow(though his spelling is atrocious at times) I can give you some pepto for your gut because obviously it is off.
Snow-I can't get over that 1st post I referenced earlier. In the game just enough to be in
I need to see who I missed
Edit
I missed way-I forgot what I was thinking about him, I need to reread on him and get back.
Comments are welcomed and appreciated
---This message was edited on 2017-04-09 11:23:16---
This space is intentionally left blank.
I will make my deb's list from memory because I can't copy and paste
Bobi-i am all over the place with her. Says she is not rotten, I want to believe that, but what the sticking point for me is, is she wants the seer to divine her. If you are a good egg why would you want the seer to waste a divine? But then again is it a ploy to make the seer dismiss her as a rotten possibility?? I need some clarification on that.
Brin-I made a comment last game that she has good insights and I was missing them(she was a wolf) has she adapted and that is the reason for her Sophie fixation???
Cat- I never have a clue, you really need to be more of a chatty catty!!
Cab- I can't get a read on her this game, is she being quieter than normal??
Sophie- other than brin's gut I don't see anything, because dan's reasoning does sound sound
Dan- if Sophie is rotten then dan could very well be rotten. His points make sense, coherent and able to follow(though his spelling is atrocious at times) I can give you some pepto for your gut because obviously it is off.
Snow-I can't get over that 1st post I referenced earlier. In the game just enough to be in
I need to see who I missed
Edit
I missed way-I forgot what I was thinking about him, I need to reread on him and get back.
Comments are welcomed and appreciated
---This message was edited on 2017-04-09 11:23:16---
This space is intentionally left blank.
Work in progress
Bobi cab and brin voted who in round 1 to help tal
Brin cab and dan voted for who in round 2(who was shot)
Snow piqued my interest and voted Sophie, discussions were already about Sophie so appears to be a reasonable vote
I am sure I missed something
So just based on The Who vote I will count brin, cab and Dan as human. There was absolutely no reason to bus a fellow wolf in that round(unless you are Harry).
---This message was edited on 2017-04-09 11:47:46---
This space is intentionally left blank.
Bobi cab and brin voted who in round 1 to help tal
Brin cab and dan voted for who in round 2(who was shot)
Snow piqued my interest and voted Sophie, discussions were already about Sophie so appears to be a reasonable vote
I am sure I missed something
So just based on The Who vote I will count brin, cab and Dan as human. There was absolutely no reason to bus a fellow wolf in that round(unless you are Harry).
---This message was edited on 2017-04-09 11:47:46---
This space is intentionally left blank.
If you are a good egg why would you want the seer to waste a divine?
Why are you under the impression that the seer learning a human identity is a 'waste of a divination'?
and wolves cant afford to frame someone in night 3 with the seer still out there, im not sure why people dont seem to appreciate this
---This message was edited on 2017-04-09 11:36:07---
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
It just kinda does to me, the seer needs to find the wolves and fast, to me it would be like froggy saying I am human but seer divine me. Bobi said I am not rotten, not quite the same. I don't know, it was just something that popped out at me, I could be fixated on it for no reason, that is why I wanted comments
This space is intentionally left blank.
This space is intentionally left blank.
Yes Spider..
My list was everyone is a wolf..
I thought it was funny..
And deb,,In one game you say I could be a wolf because I don't post enough.
Then the next game you say I might be a wolf because I post to much..
I don't have a great list of suspects yet but deb is at the top of it..
Hope our seer has got at least one wolf cornered..
The early bird gets the worm,but the second rat gets the cheese..
My list was everyone is a wolf..
I thought it was funny..
And deb,,In one game you say I could be a wolf because I don't post enough.
Then the next game you say I might be a wolf because I post to much..
I don't have a great list of suspects yet but deb is at the top of it..
Hope our seer has got at least one wolf cornered..
The early bird gets the worm,but the second rat gets the cheese..
The seers job is to learn as many identities as possible of players likely to be around in the mid/end game. Divining highly suspect players, likely to be shot regardless, is a bad seer strategy. 3 human divines is very very powerful, especially if they are of players such as Cat in this game (little to go off of). Glory hunting seers can score home runs when they hit, but also come up empty when they end up divining people who are shot soon anyway. But I agree with you, that Bradon's plea is not necessarily wholesome so Im not disputing the subjective part of your commentary.
My bad spelling is because I've mostly been posting from my phone, but I probably wouldn't mind too much even if was at computer.
---This message was edited on 2017-04-09 11:46:35---
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
My bad spelling is because I've mostly been posting from my phone, but I probably wouldn't mind too much even if was at computer.
---This message was edited on 2017-04-09 11:46:35---
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
I would rather have a chatty catty but that doesn't mean I can't suspect you, I do want my cake and eat it too
Dan-true. Like I said, wasn't totally clear on my suspicion and wanted to see what others thought. And I was just giving you a hard time about your spelling
This space is intentionally left blank.
Dan-true. Like I said, wasn't totally clear on my suspicion and wanted to see what others thought. And I was just giving you a hard time about your spelling
This space is intentionally left blank.
Other's will have to better judge snow's play as Im not really qualified
My brief Deb's list
Bradon - The Jayo eating puts a bright spotlight over her head, this is balanced by her actions in Round 1. These are most fun cases, as there is strong evidence to point to wolf, and strong evidence to point to human. For now, totally on the fence but leaning human
BRIN - Must be human
Cab - Also gotta be human
Cat - Nothing to go on really, wolf suspect by default
Deb - Coming around, in the middle of the pack as a suspect
Sophie - I'll relent on my insistene she's human, certainly could be wrong, but her actions in Round 1 would be really odd if she was a wolf
Way - He put Who in a early round 1 majority (despite later decisively escaping it) Who also thanked him for saving him which I still think is very odd if they were both wolves. Leaning human, but if Bradon is human, the Jayo eating (in my own stream of consciousness way) seems like could be him
Snow - Iunno, suspect by default but havent developed a strong sense either way
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
My brief Deb's list
Bradon - The Jayo eating puts a bright spotlight over her head, this is balanced by her actions in Round 1. These are most fun cases, as there is strong evidence to point to wolf, and strong evidence to point to human. For now, totally on the fence but leaning human
BRIN - Must be human
Cab - Also gotta be human
Cat - Nothing to go on really, wolf suspect by default
Deb - Coming around, in the middle of the pack as a suspect
Sophie - I'll relent on my insistene she's human, certainly could be wrong, but her actions in Round 1 would be really odd if she was a wolf
Way - He put Who in a early round 1 majority (despite later decisively escaping it) Who also thanked him for saving him which I still think is very odd if they were both wolves. Leaning human, but if Bradon is human, the Jayo eating (in my own stream of consciousness way) seems like could be him
Snow - Iunno, suspect by default but havent developed a strong sense either way
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
I am tempted to vote Sophie just to put it to rest, could be wrong but I think it might be a mistake, I don't know just bouncing back and forth with her
For now I will vote snow but I can be convinced
This space is intentionally left blank.
For now I will vote snow but I can be convinced
This space is intentionally left blank.
Let her post at least
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
Asking the Seer to divine you isn't much of a play in my book
I do think Jayo rattled a cage or two with his list, or that eating him would make it look that to be the case
I'm inclined to think it's the former and just gonna go with that feeling then and go with Brandon
Next round Seer will come outI'm sure
Should come out anyway I think
I never make mitsakes
I do think Jayo rattled a cage or two with his list, or that eating him would make it look that to be the case
I'm inclined to think it's the former and just gonna go with that feeling then and go with Brandon
Next round Seer will come outI'm sure
Should come out anyway I think
I never make mitsakes
I am here. Sorry rough day. I don't know what to say to convince you all that I am a good egg. I thought I'd give Talan a fighting chance but didn't want to do it at the expense of another player. Brin took that and twisted it to me being a wolf. I don't know how she guessed correctly about Who we all get those feelings sometimes that turn out right. I'm just saying, her instincts were'nt right about me.
Voting Snow to give myself a fighting chance. at least i'm tied in a min maj rather than being a majority alone.
bradon182001 voted for Sophie-Drake
bRIN voted for Sophie-Drake
caberet voted for bradon182001
catmandon voted for debc1
debc1 voted for snowmonster
Sophie-Drake voted for snowmonster
The_Spider voted for catmandon
Waylander voted for bradon182001
---This message was edited on 2017-04-09 17:19:12---
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
Im pretty frozen up about this decision
more ideas would help
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
more ideas would help
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
Was out of town for the weekend, Sorry for my lack of involvement, but that was the reason. Before we left Friday, I was busy packing for a couple days, so. . . . . I was preoccupied. I was able to check in earlier today, but not really catch up. I've been home 5 minutes, have to eat a late dinner, then I'll come back and read through the posts. I did notice I've got 2 votes. At this point, I have no choice but to vote Sophie - to give myself a fighting chance. Later, I will read through this round carefully. If anything catches my eye, I will share.
Take all sorrow out of life and you take away all richness, and depth, and tenderness. The capacity of sorrow belongs to our grandeur. It is the furnace that melts hearts together in love.
Take all sorrow out of life and you take away all richness, and depth, and tenderness. The capacity of sorrow belongs to our grandeur. It is the furnace that melts hearts together in love.
You have the option of voting Bradon as well
Ive had work weekends on the road so I sympathize snow, but a nice interesting post would keep my vote off you. I could even go Sophie just to clear the issue, but plenty of time.....I think we need to bring some more egg puns back into the game
---This message was edited on 2017-04-09 20:16:06---
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
Ive had work weekends on the road so I sympathize snow, but a nice interesting post would keep my vote off you. I could even go Sophie just to clear the issue, but plenty of time.....I think we need to bring some more egg puns back into the game
---This message was edited on 2017-04-09 20:16:06---
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
As to Sophie why did you vote Snow instead of Bradon?
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
The_Spider wrote:
because snow was the first one I saw that I could tie up with me...no other reason. But my vote is there now. We'll see if it helps me.
---This message was edited on 2017-04-09 20:24:20---
As to Sophie why did you vote Snow instead of Bradon?
because snow was the first one I saw that I could tie up with me...no other reason. But my vote is there now. We'll see if it helps me.
---This message was edited on 2017-04-09 20:24:20---
As for my decision to vote Sophie, I had skimmed over the votes, and actually didn't see that Bradon had more than 1 vote on her.
Keeping my vote where it's at. At this point, I don't suspect anyone else more than I do Sophie. I promise to be more active, and insightful, if possible from now on. I can share how I feel up to this point about everyone though, if that helps. lol
bradon182001 - Low on my radar, but got a little too defensive early in the round
bRIN - could go either way
caberet - feeling she's human, but can't explain why. A gut feeling? Maybe.
catmandon - slightly suspicious
debc1 - slightly more than slightly suspicious
Sophie-Drake - same as deb
The_Spider - acting pretty dern human
Waylander - slightly suspicious
Ok, I may be wrong with my assessment, but this is how I'm feeling about everyone, at this point. This weekend trip kinda got in my way with this game, so I may be waaaayyyyy off, but thought I'd share since I haven't been that active.
Take all sorrow out of life and you take away all richness, and depth, and tenderness. The capacity of sorrow belongs to our grandeur. It is the furnace that melts hearts together in love.
Keeping my vote where it's at. At this point, I don't suspect anyone else more than I do Sophie. I promise to be more active, and insightful, if possible from now on. I can share how I feel up to this point about everyone though, if that helps. lol
bradon182001 - Low on my radar, but got a little too defensive early in the round
bRIN - could go either way
caberet - feeling she's human, but can't explain why. A gut feeling? Maybe.
catmandon - slightly suspicious
debc1 - slightly more than slightly suspicious
Sophie-Drake - same as deb
The_Spider - acting pretty dern human
Waylander - slightly suspicious
Ok, I may be wrong with my assessment, but this is how I'm feeling about everyone, at this point. This weekend trip kinda got in my way with this game, so I may be waaaayyyyy off, but thought I'd share since I haven't been that active.
Take all sorrow out of life and you take away all richness, and depth, and tenderness. The capacity of sorrow belongs to our grandeur. It is the furnace that melts hearts together in love.
Well, I don't know what to add
Bobi slightly more human than the rest of the suspects due to the fact she voted who in round 1
Edit
Going sophie
---This message was edited on 2017-04-09 22:22:11---
This space is intentionally left blank.
Bobi slightly more human than the rest of the suspects due to the fact she voted who in round 1
Edit
Going sophie
---This message was edited on 2017-04-09 22:22:11---
This space is intentionally left blank.
I'm not 100% sure of anyone right now..
I do have a feeling about deb,but I have thought of others too.
I will make things interesting and change my vote to bardon and make a tie..
They say odds are that a wolf will be chosen ...
Hope that that is right,bradon is my 3th suspect..
The early bird gets the worm,but the second rat gets the cheese..
I do have a feeling about deb,but I have thought of others too.
I will make things interesting and change my vote to bardon and make a tie..
They say odds are that a wolf will be chosen ...
Hope that that is right,bradon is my 3th suspect..
The early bird gets the worm,but the second rat gets the cheese..
You cannot post messages in previous rounds.
Follow Braingle!