The Werewolf Game
Game #3097: Witch Hunt
This private game is moderated by masoni88. Please read the rules and contact the moderator with any questions or concerns about this game.
This game finished in 8 rounds.
Sorry all... Long day at work. I did not expect the night to end so quickly. (It had only begun when I left for work.)
Harry was the Sheriff.
No messages from the talkboxes. Your government is silent and your Witch Hunters are too. With the entirety of the cult left, you need all the help you can get!
---This message was edited on 2014-12-08 19:59:41---
It's when you draw it you realize what it really looks like
Harry was the Sheriff.
No messages from the talkboxes. Your government is silent and your Witch Hunters are too. With the entirety of the cult left, you need all the help you can get!
---This message was edited on 2014-12-08 19:59:41---
It's when you draw it you realize what it really looks like
wow that was a short night
edit: why did they eat Harri?
---This message was edited on 2014-12-08 10:58:23---
It's when you draw it you realize what it really looks like
edit: why did they eat Harri?
---This message was edited on 2014-12-08 10:58:23---
It's when you draw it you realize what it really looks like
Just woke up. Head hurts. Must kick people out earlier.
I was checking in to see who got shot and was surprised to see we are already in Round 3. That must have been an extremely short night. Interesting.
Also, read the end of last round and am waiting for our mod to tell me why I'm so special that I'm not wolf dinner. Grateful, but baffled.
I was checking in to see who got shot and was surprised to see we are already in Round 3. That must have been an extremely short night. Interesting.
Also, read the end of last round and am waiting for our mod to tell me why I'm so special that I'm not wolf dinner. Grateful, but baffled.
I am just speculating here but there are several roles that can dictate the eatings/shootings you were likely saved by that.
Either that or the mod is sweet on you
Maybe the dog only brings the ball back because he thinks you like throwing it.
Either that or the mod is sweet on you
Maybe the dog only brings the ball back because he thinks you like throwing it.
Mayor protected you right? Or sheriff or something
I'll be able to talk more when I get out of school in a couple hours
Happy ever after in the marketplace, Desmond lets the children lend a hand. Molly stays at home and does her pretty face, and in the evening she's the singer with the band!
I'll be able to talk more when I get out of school in a couple hours
Happy ever after in the marketplace, Desmond lets the children lend a hand. Molly stays at home and does her pretty face, and in the evening she's the singer with the band!
Harry eating early again....weak sauce....will think things over
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
Hey guys sorry I haven't been on much in previous rounds. My Uncle had a heart attack saturday night so i haven't been near any computers this weekend and my phone sucks. There definately been some weird eatings and shootings. I'm about to read over everything before I vote..
Things are not always as they appear
Things are not always as they appear
Ok guys I'm about to get off work and I might be able to check in later and post or change my vote tonight on my phone if i see fit, but it messes up alot. I wont be back to a computer till 8am cst when I get back to work.
I'm going to go ahead and vote and kind of lay out my theory.
I'm voting spider. I want to see everyone elses opinions as well.
I think we may have made a mistake putting him in power. here is my theory
He is very smart. if we go back to round 1 he made a promise
The_Spider wrote:
Now as I said I've mulled this over for a couple hours. if this were to be brought up what could his arguments be for eating harry.... Someone was framing him.. why would he ever eat harry if he clearly stated this in round 1 but!! I think he would do this to try to throw suspicions. As I said he's very smart from what i've seen in past games with him.
Sorry for rambling. I don't know who his accomplices may be. I will try to get back on later. what does everyone else think?
Things are not always as they appear
I'm going to go ahead and vote and kind of lay out my theory.
I'm voting spider. I want to see everyone elses opinions as well.
I think we may have made a mistake putting him in power. here is my theory
He is very smart. if we go back to round 1 he made a promise
The_Spider wrote:
Actually jayo just added a nice spark to the typical round 1 doldrums,
A vote for spid is a vote for abuse of mayoral powers, a vote for embezzlement from the town coffers, and a vote for a newly instituted deb fund.....also something bad will happen to harry
A vote for spid is a vote for abuse of mayoral powers, a vote for embezzlement from the town coffers, and a vote for a newly instituted deb fund.....also something bad will happen to harry
Now as I said I've mulled this over for a couple hours. if this were to be brought up what could his arguments be for eating harry.... Someone was framing him.. why would he ever eat harry if he clearly stated this in round 1 but!! I think he would do this to try to throw suspicions. As I said he's very smart from what i've seen in past games with him.
Sorry for rambling. I don't know who his accomplices may be. I will try to get back on later. what does everyone else think?
Things are not always as they appear
Way over thinking things, why are ppl taking the role of mayor seriously? Am I really going to taken to task for a joke I made prior to any announcement of mayor, I didn't even vote for a mayor, that's how so very very little I cared or care about being mayor
Some ppl have been on without posting, which annoying if nothing else
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
Some ppl have been on without posting, which annoying if nothing else
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
Taking a bit cuz I'm thinking while watching the news
But yeah as you've shown @bb our first instinct would be to accuse him, not that he's being framed... Also seems like more of a throwaway joke than a "clue"
Although I might be more inclined to watch the people not doing anything...
Softball looks pretty clear in my mind - there would have been no reason to change the focus of the game from jessey.
Happy ever after in the marketplace, Desmond lets the children lend a hand. Molly stays at home and does her pretty face, and in the evening she's the singer with the band!
But yeah as you've shown @bb our first instinct would be to accuse him, not that he's being framed... Also seems like more of a throwaway joke than a "clue"
Although I might be more inclined to watch the people not doing anything...
Softball looks pretty clear in my mind - there would have been no reason to change the focus of the game from jessey.
Happy ever after in the marketplace, Desmond lets the children lend a hand. Molly stays at home and does her pretty face, and in the evening she's the singer with the band!
It is an interesting theory and I suppose there could be ssomething to it lol
I am just feeding the kids before bed then I'll be able to post more.
Maybe the dog only brings the ball back because he thinks you like throwing it.
I am just feeding the kids before bed then I'll be able to post more.
Maybe the dog only brings the ball back because he thinks you like throwing it.
I'm not too surprised by the Harry eating, Harry seems to be a choice feast for the second round. My bad for not voting last round guys, couldn't get in at school due to some new guidelines.
"I need to be myself. I can't be no one else." - Noel Gallagher
"I need to be myself. I can't be no one else." - Noel Gallagher
checking in
maybe people should do a list
This space is intentionally left blank.
maybe people should do a list
This space is intentionally left blank.
I am not sure about Softy being clear. She started out with Deb, the said shebliked the Jess-y vote but that zhe also suspected BB. Seems more indecisive than anything to me.
There were already enough votes on Jess that there was a good chance that she would be the one shot. Attempting to start a second majority on Bb would be a good strategy if she is a wolf. That way she can claim to have avoided hitting a human.
Maybe the dog only brings the ball back because he thinks you like throwing it.
There were already enough votes on Jess that there was a good chance that she would be the one shot. Attempting to start a second majority on Bb would be a good strategy if she is a wolf. That way she can claim to have avoided hitting a human.
Maybe the dog only brings the ball back because he thinks you like throwing it.
Yeah that's way to premature to clear someone with,leaning human fine, but a clear is over the top
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
i don't think Spider would eat harri early in the game :p pretty he sure was just messing around with that comment
i'm not really suspecting spider atm (not saying he couldn't be a wolf cause he's genius at this game) but he's definitely not on the top of my list
It's when you draw it you realize what it really looks like
i'm not really suspecting spider atm (not saying he couldn't be a wolf cause he's genius at this game) but he's definitely not on the top of my list
It's when you draw it you realize what it really looks like
Ill bite Deb...but filling out gradually as i do other things (i.e. Netflix)
bbgrl - Not sure, never seen her as a wolf so playing by ear
cccgirl - I hate playing 'against' the mod, but the wording of masonis warning leans me toward cc being human, but I freely admit I could be 100% wrong on that
celtichero - Celt is normally really active and involved when he is a wolf, the contrast is usually pretty obvious, leaning human
debc1 - I dont know, not much to go on either way, neutral on Deb
Evita - Was in a fight for her life early on (and I have a good idea of who was on in Rd 1 at the end with the possibility of saving/or not saving her), Id like to keep Evi around for a bit, but no strong feelings either way.
HABS2933 - Not really sure....she's posted a lot so I owe her posts another look before I pass judgement
koin_era345 - Questionable, the quickness the 'clear' Soft sends of a slight persistent defender vibe, but could just be overznxious to 'solve' the game, which is a trap I fall into as well
Lawlor88 - Other than the vote/no post thing, not much to be suspicious about, wolves with any experience should avoid such obvious mistakes anyway
slammngirl92 - not sure......she'll be useful when other IDs are known but not sure right now
xxsoftballxx13x - I dont know, Im always suspicious of softballs play, she has tended to 'overexplain' her self this game. Being a little to pedantic and verbiose in explaining her actions. Wolves like to make it clear they are 'being logical' with their thought processes, a possible suspect
---This message was edited on 2014-12-08 19:44:40---
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
bbgrl - Not sure, never seen her as a wolf so playing by ear
cccgirl - I hate playing 'against' the mod, but the wording of masonis warning leans me toward cc being human, but I freely admit I could be 100% wrong on that
celtichero - Celt is normally really active and involved when he is a wolf, the contrast is usually pretty obvious, leaning human
debc1 - I dont know, not much to go on either way, neutral on Deb
Evita - Was in a fight for her life early on (and I have a good idea of who was on in Rd 1 at the end with the possibility of saving/or not saving her), Id like to keep Evi around for a bit, but no strong feelings either way.
HABS2933 - Not really sure....she's posted a lot so I owe her posts another look before I pass judgement
koin_era345 - Questionable, the quickness the 'clear' Soft sends of a slight persistent defender vibe, but could just be overznxious to 'solve' the game, which is a trap I fall into as well
Lawlor88 - Other than the vote/no post thing, not much to be suspicious about, wolves with any experience should avoid such obvious mistakes anyway
slammngirl92 - not sure......she'll be useful when other IDs are known but not sure right now
xxsoftballxx13x - I dont know, Im always suspicious of softballs play, she has tended to 'overexplain' her self this game. Being a little to pedantic and verbiose in explaining her actions. Wolves like to make it clear they are 'being logical' with their thought processes, a possible suspect
---This message was edited on 2014-12-08 19:44:40---
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
The_Spider wrote:
You left yourself off the list ... i find that highly suspect
Maybe the dog only brings the ball back because he thinks you like throwing it.
Ill bite Deb...but filling out gradually as i do other things (i.e. Netflix)
bbgrl
cccgirl
celtichero
debc1
Evita
HABS2933
koin_era345
Lawlor88
slammngirl92
xxsoftballxx13x
bbgrl
cccgirl
celtichero
debc1
Evita
HABS2933
koin_era345
Lawlor88
slammngirl92
xxsoftballxx13x
You left yourself off the list ... i find that highly suspect
Maybe the dog only brings the ball back because he thinks you like throwing it.
Just on my way home from work. Short night... Will update the top post when home
Yeah thats what I meant - thinking she's human... not clear.
Not a lot of thoughts rn
I dont see any reason to suspect spid over others but the harry eating doesn't really make it more likely hes human. if the other 2 wolves voted to eat harry, this sentence
Happy ever after in the marketplace, Desmond lets the children lend a hand. Molly stays at home and does her pretty face, and in the evening she's the singer with the band!
Not a lot of thoughts rn
I dont see any reason to suspect spid over others but the harry eating doesn't really make it more likely hes human. if the other 2 wolves voted to eat harry, this sentence
Harry eating early again....weak sauce....will think things over
would make decent sense in context.
Happy ever after in the marketplace, Desmond lets the children lend a hand. Molly stays at home and does her pretty face, and in the evening she's the singer with the band!
If you conclude I wouldnt eat Harry (which Im not saying you should conclude or not conclude that) it absolutely makes it "more likely" I am human, as it makes it less likely Harry is eaten by definition.
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
But as Join said, if the other two wolves over ruled you, then that comment would make sense if directed at them and not at the room as a whole. I don't really think you'd eat Harry this early. But then, maybe you would since it would be unexpected.....
Of course, the wolves may not have much choice. Three of them, both Spider and Ccc under protection. That is five players that they couldn't eat. Then of course there are the players that could not be touched.
Depending on the roles they've been assigned, there could be reasons not clear to the rest of us that other players were left alone. They wouldn't eat the witch either... HP may have been one of only a couple players that it made sense (to a wolf) to eat.
I'm looking at Slammed and maybe Join.
Maybe the dog only brings the ball back because he thinks you like throwing it.
Of course, the wolves may not have much choice. Three of them, both Spider and Ccc under protection. That is five players that they couldn't eat. Then of course there are the players that could not be touched.
Depending on the roles they've been assigned, there could be reasons not clear to the rest of us that other players were left alone. They wouldn't eat the witch either... HP may have been one of only a couple players that it made sense (to a wolf) to eat.
I'm looking at Slammed and maybe Join.
Maybe the dog only brings the ball back because he thinks you like throwing it.
That theory I dont think has ever panned out, it could just as simply be a comment directed at the room as a whole...so its a non-starter......I actually think you might be a wolf HABS, your continued and indirect casting of accusations is becoming ominous
(i.e. what I think your doing is backpeddling into a position where you can get me shot after early feedback against me...you arnt leading the charge but you are planting seeds for others to pick up on)
---This message was edited on 2014-12-08 20:56:10---
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
(i.e. what I think your doing is backpeddling into a position where you can get me shot after early feedback against me...you arnt leading the charge but you are planting seeds for others to pick up on)
---This message was edited on 2014-12-08 20:56:10---
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
Nah, I'm not a wolf. Just a lowly human with no special knowledge or powers .. just trying to figure this whole thing out.. trying to work out who could be partnered with who and what other role they may have. I really don't think you are a wolf, but maybe you are the witch...
Maybe the dog only brings the ball back because he thinks you like throwing it.
Maybe the dog only brings the ball back because he thinks you like throwing it.
CCC, I forgot to mention, it was the exorcist who prevented you from being eaten last night.
Well....im open minded to you especially as your top shelf activity level is helpful, but those who are aiming at me give me the sense they are hoping to take advantage of the bb vote without taking the lead...a little....well spider could be suspcious cause of x, and hoping someone else votes me without doing the deed themselves
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
I see the accusations have been flying this round. Normally, a quick turnaround like this would be odd, but, considering the cultists have a talkbox, they most likely planned their kill throughout the day round and for some reason decided to act on their vote less than two hours after the round ended, if my math is correct.
Spider, I always over explain myself. I always feel the need to defend myself, when I am human and wolf alike. My personality, outside and within this game is an introvert who does not take dislike/hostility well. It's a stupid character flaw.
I realize I just over explained.
Anyways, last round, I believe there were two/three votes on Jess-ey when I placed my vote for bbgrl. I did say that I was suspicious of both of them, and I chose to vote the way I did because I did not think one warranted more concern than the other.
Sorry about your uncle, bbgrl. Hope all will be well.
Spider, I always over explain myself. I always feel the need to defend myself, when I am human and wolf alike. My personality, outside and within this game is an introvert who does not take dislike/hostility well. It's a stupid character flaw.
I realize I just over explained.
Anyways, last round, I believe there were two/three votes on Jess-ey when I placed my vote for bbgrl. I did say that I was suspicious of both of them, and I chose to vote the way I did because I did not think one warranted more concern than the other.
Sorry about your uncle, bbgrl. Hope all will be well.
Spid how come you keep saying you want to keep evi around? I mean, game-wise, is there any reason for that or just because evi is cool
Might look at bb... I know when i'm a wolf i'll focus on a little detail to get my fair share of strategizing out of the way without having to make a lot of accusations or develop theories.
Happy ever after in the marketplace, Desmond lets the children lend a hand. Molly stays at home and does her pretty face, and in the evening she's the singer with the band!
Might look at bb... I know when i'm a wolf i'll focus on a little detail to get my fair share of strategizing out of the way without having to make a lot of accusations or develop theories.
Happy ever after in the marketplace, Desmond lets the children lend a hand. Molly stays at home and does her pretty face, and in the evening she's the singer with the band!
I've said it twice as far as I know (explaining past actions doesnt count)...in Round one I saved her because she was a "worthy foe" from the last game and I prefered to keep her around (I also got back with 5 minutes left in round so wasnt entirely privy on how the round got to where it was)
As for this round, yes, whenever someone gets put in majorities, especially in non-bussing situations, it rules out combinations, if Evi is human, shooting her gets us almost nowhere, while later on, when the numbers shrink, we can rule out more pairs, which worked very well in must lynch of last game (Cab just didnt adhere to the theory )
I really feel like you guys are throwing 'feelers' out to see who wants to shoot me....bb stepping up and doing it is a reason id more think her human than the rest
---This message was edited on 2014-12-08 21:50:22---
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
As for this round, yes, whenever someone gets put in majorities, especially in non-bussing situations, it rules out combinations, if Evi is human, shooting her gets us almost nowhere, while later on, when the numbers shrink, we can rule out more pairs, which worked very well in must lynch of last game (Cab just didnt adhere to the theory )
I really feel like you guys are throwing 'feelers' out to see who wants to shoot me....bb stepping up and doing it is a reason id more think her human than the rest
---This message was edited on 2014-12-08 21:50:22---
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
Sorry to get on so late. I felt so sick today.
I could see bb eating harry, definitely. I don't think spid would eat harry because he likes the competition but he could have to frame someone.
Right now I'm definitely learning towards bb, but I will see what others think.
Maybe we can get a majority going this round.
I could see bb eating harry, definitely. I don't think spid would eat harry because he likes the competition but he could have to frame someone.
Right now I'm definitely learning towards bb, but I will see what others think.
Maybe we can get a majority going this round.
Not tryna shoot you spid, basically everyone has been accused at some point
I agree with slamm time for another vote on the table as well so I'll go ahead and lock bb in for the time being
Happy ever after in the marketplace, Desmond lets the children lend a hand. Molly stays at home and does her pretty face, and in the evening she's the singer with the band!
I agree with slamm time for another vote on the table as well so I'll go ahead and lock bb in for the time being
Happy ever after in the marketplace, Desmond lets the children lend a hand. Molly stays at home and does her pretty face, and in the evening she's the singer with the band!
my list
bbgrl - not sure could be preoccupied with real life
cccgirl - not sure
celtichero - ok not sure again
debc1 - am sure human
Evita - leaning human
HABS2933 - not sure
koin_era345 - also not sure
Lawlor88 - sorry i don't buy it, leaning wolf
slammngirl92 - thinking human
The_Spider - don't know what is the deal with dan this game, seems off, to cavalier
xxsoftballxx13x - kinda iffy
i don't think we should discount the dan eating harry, no i retrack that, the wolves do have a box, but it could be no choice(harry's eating) not sure
This space is intentionally left blank.
bbgrl - not sure could be preoccupied with real life
cccgirl - not sure
celtichero - ok not sure again
debc1 - am sure human
Evita - leaning human
HABS2933 - not sure
koin_era345 - also not sure
Lawlor88 - sorry i don't buy it, leaning wolf
slammngirl92 - thinking human
The_Spider - don't know what is the deal with dan this game, seems off, to cavalier
xxsoftballxx13x - kinda iffy
i don't think we should discount the dan eating harry, no i retrack that, the wolves do have a box, but it could be no choice(harry's eating) not sure
This space is intentionally left blank.
my double post
not sure i will be back on before night so i will go for law
This space is intentionally left blank.
not sure i will be back on before night so i will go for law
This space is intentionally left blank.
First off, BB, hugs go out to you. I hope your uncle is ok.
Ok, back to the game -
I love Deb's recaps. They're pretty much, "Not sure...not sure...not sure...but I'M human!" LOL.
Looking at the votes, I can tell everyone is just as lost as I am. That's NOT good. I will spit out my thoughts:
* Spider is coming off just a wee bit paranoid. He keeps saying everyone is trying to plant the seed to build a case to shoot him. I don't see that. Spider, don't take this to mean I'm building a case to shoot you
* Koin seemed a bit accusatory / trigger happy in earlier rounds, so at the beginning, he was suspect. At the beginning of this round, I was sure he and Spider were on different teams, though not sure which was which. However, he's seeming more reasonable now...
* BB seems a little off - I observed that before - but we also know she has a family situation going on. So off because of wolfiness or off because of RL stuff...i'm not sure.
* Deb and Lawlor are definitely on different teams. Each has been in the majority at some point for what seemed to me to be flimsy reasons. All of a sudden Deb is sure he's a wolf again, but like before, I don't see any reasoning. This is not a defense for Lawlor, who hasn't posted much, but I would like to know where Deb is coming from. I bet you one of them is a wolf.
*Softball seems pretty human to me. I admit I'm biased for Softie because I do the exact same thing - I'm natural introverted and an overexplainer (which usually gets me in trouble).
*Slammngrl is a wild card. Her idea for targeting the seer witch may have been an innocent brainstorm or a deliberate distraction. So she's not the witch, but could be a wolf.
* Celtic is halfway in the game. I've been away from this for a couple of years, so I tend to believe the earlier opinion posted that maybe he's not a wolf because else he would be more engaged.
I know I'm missing someone, but I'm going to bed. This is Round 3 and I don't want to throw a wild vote - it's getting late in the game for that. I'll re-read in the AM, see who makes the most sense, and vote then.
Ok, back to the game -
I love Deb's recaps. They're pretty much, "Not sure...not sure...not sure...but I'M human!" LOL.
Looking at the votes, I can tell everyone is just as lost as I am. That's NOT good. I will spit out my thoughts:
* Spider is coming off just a wee bit paranoid. He keeps saying everyone is trying to plant the seed to build a case to shoot him. I don't see that. Spider, don't take this to mean I'm building a case to shoot you
* Koin seemed a bit accusatory / trigger happy in earlier rounds, so at the beginning, he was suspect. At the beginning of this round, I was sure he and Spider were on different teams, though not sure which was which. However, he's seeming more reasonable now...
* BB seems a little off - I observed that before - but we also know she has a family situation going on. So off because of wolfiness or off because of RL stuff...i'm not sure.
* Deb and Lawlor are definitely on different teams. Each has been in the majority at some point for what seemed to me to be flimsy reasons. All of a sudden Deb is sure he's a wolf again, but like before, I don't see any reasoning. This is not a defense for Lawlor, who hasn't posted much, but I would like to know where Deb is coming from. I bet you one of them is a wolf.
*Softball seems pretty human to me. I admit I'm biased for Softie because I do the exact same thing - I'm natural introverted and an overexplainer (which usually gets me in trouble).
*Slammngrl is a wild card. Her idea for targeting the seer witch may have been an innocent brainstorm or a deliberate distraction. So she's not the witch, but could be a wolf.
* Celtic is halfway in the game. I've been away from this for a couple of years, so I tend to believe the earlier opinion posted that maybe he's not a wolf because else he would be more engaged.
I know I'm missing someone, but I'm going to bed. This is Round 3 and I don't want to throw a wild vote - it's getting late in the game for that. I'll re-read in the AM, see who makes the most sense, and vote then.
Gah. I missed HABs. Just as well - I can't read HABs at all...yet. I'll come back in the morning.
I'm gonna join the vote on bb.
Since no one is really making a move, I'll act.
Since no one is really making a move, I'll act.
And i think we need to keep eyes out for spid and evi. Same team definitely.
Either spid is full of himself or they are both wolves and he's protecting her. I know she hadn't played wwg for as long as most of us.
Either spid is full of himself or they are both wolves and he's protecting her. I know she hadn't played wwg for as long as most of us.
cccgirl wrote:
I'm the same way too. Until I get to know somebody, I will barely say a word. At my last job, it took me almost 6 months to say anything to anyone that was not work related and even then it was quick and quite.
I also suffer from "Middle Child Syndrome"
I am still leaning Slamm, her first post just above mine, she just says she is going to join the BB vote but does not give a reason, other to say no one is making a move.
To me she has been "off" and unpredictable this entire game. We only have a couple more rounds to get this right, as we get into the later rounds, this could be dangerous.
---This message was edited on 2014-12-09 05:17:46---
Maybe the dog only brings the ball back because he thinks you like throwing it.
... I'm biased for Softie because I do the exact same thing - I'm natural introverted and an overexplainer (which usually gets me in trouble).
I'm the same way too. Until I get to know somebody, I will barely say a word. At my last job, it took me almost 6 months to say anything to anyone that was not work related and even then it was quick and quite.
I also suffer from "Middle Child Syndrome"
I am still leaning Slamm, her first post just above mine, she just says she is going to join the BB vote but does not give a reason, other to say no one is making a move.
To me she has been "off" and unpredictable this entire game. We only have a couple more rounds to get this right, as we get into the later rounds, this could be dangerous.
---This message was edited on 2014-12-09 05:17:46---
Maybe the dog only brings the ball back because he thinks you like throwing it.
Habs, I posted a reason in the previous post before I voted about how I could see her eating harry....
And i think we need to keep eyes out for spid and evi. Same team definitely.
Either spid is full of himself or they are both wolves and he's protecting her. I know she hadn't played wwg for as long as most of us.
Either spid is full of himself or they are both wolves and he's protecting her. I know she hadn't played wwg for as long as most of us.
Yeah you guys really need to tone down the "same team" stuff. Considering most of the players are playing from a position of ignorance, these conclusions often make no sense. So how would you conclude Spid/Evi are either Wolf/Wolf or Human/Human, that conclusions makes absoluteely no sense at all. Human/Human almost NEVER makes sense as a conclusion
Slamm the only one whos ego seems ruffled is yours because I voted for you. As I explained, Evi was a "worthy foe" last game, and yes, I think she deserved more than a Rd 1 bullet. With 5 minutes left I offered her a way out without full context of the round. Sorry that because you were the one I targetted is it has to be some big conspiracy, yeah and I dont care what the game count says, Evi has far more wwg "experience" than you do
I OFTEN argue that ppl in majorities should be left till later, I made the same allusion as recently ad last round...so pretending this is about ego is willful ignorance
you should just admit you are offended about getting voted for and move on
---This message was edited on 2014-12-09 07:22:23---
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
Hey guys sorry I'm so late to the game! Just how long was the night exactly? Didn't think I'd miss so much of the day :/
I kinda get the BB vote although I'm gonna hold off voting for anyone for now because I don't have anyone popping up on my radar at the moment. Will re-read over the last few rounds and attempt to make an informed decision
I kinda get the BB vote although I'm gonna hold off voting for anyone for now because I don't have anyone popping up on my radar at the moment. Will re-read over the last few rounds and attempt to make an informed decision
Also evi missed a vote iirc, ergo she is less lekely to ignore seer protection if she is a wolf
If I didn't think I'd set off world war 3 I actually might vote evi here, has been quiet and can't really think of a better vote...it's a Rd early to vote for habs and no one else is a strong enough case, while evi is just sort of in the mix
---This message was edited on 2014-12-09 07:38:07---
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
If I didn't think I'd set off world war 3 I actually might vote evi here, has been quiet and can't really think of a better vote...it's a Rd early to vote for habs and no one else is a strong enough case, while evi is just sort of in the mix
---This message was edited on 2014-12-09 07:38:07---
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
On phone, I'll post deb list 2 later and vote
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
Hah, you can vote for me all you want. But it better be because I'm not playing my role well, not for your own ego and friendships but good try.
Lol what a pathetic little baby response
It's hilarious u keep refering to my ego (without any basis..how does my ego have anything to do with voting u???) When u are CLEARLY butthurt about being the one I voted for, ie ur ego was bruised
---This message was edited on 2014-12-09 08:28:42---
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
It's hilarious u keep refering to my ego (without any basis..how does my ego have anything to do with voting u???) When u are CLEARLY butthurt about being the one I voted for, ie ur ego was bruised
---This message was edited on 2014-12-09 08:28:42---
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
The_Spider wrote:
Slam preetty sure i've played this for longer than you o.o
i just realized this round will end before the deadline i have tonight (bit distracted cause i have an exam project due next week and i need to finish my part tonight) so i'll figure out a vute this time, decided not to vote last round since it would have made no real difference and i really didn't feel for any of the current majorities
i'll figure out a vote this time, just needa finish something else first
It's when you draw it you realize what it really looks like
I've said it twice as far as I know (explaining past actions doesnt count)...in Round one I saved her because she was a "worthy foe" from the last game and I prefered to keep her around (I also got back with 5 minutes left in round so wasnt entirely privy on how the round got to where it was)
saved my butt because i kicked his last game simple and logicSlam preetty sure i've played this for longer than you o.o
i just realized this round will end before the deadline i have tonight (bit distracted cause i have an exam project due next week and i need to finish my part tonight) so i'll figure out a vute this time, decided not to vote last round since it would have made no real difference and i really didn't feel for any of the current majorities
i'll figure out a vote this time, just needa finish something else first
It's when you draw it you realize what it really looks like
Not to mention, this ignores the obvious I would have simply voted waylander if I was trying to save evi (as wolf partners)
---This message was edited on 2014-12-09 08:47:11---
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
---This message was edited on 2014-12-09 08:47:11---
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
Slamm, why are you so upset over what was a random vote that did not hurt you in the end?
He didn't want to vote Evi, for whatever reason and chose to put it on you. You are still ln the game so no harm was done. That was in round 1. We are in Round 3 now - let' move on.
His reason for voting you (a better shot than Evi) is no worse than your current reason for voting BB (you could see her eating HP). Is that to say that no one else would have done it?
This ongoing "obsession" about a first round vote that turned out to be meaningless is troubling ...
Maybe the dog only brings the ball back because he thinks you like throwing it.
He didn't want to vote Evi, for whatever reason and chose to put it on you. You are still ln the game so no harm was done. That was in round 1. We are in Round 3 now - let' move on.
His reason for voting you (a better shot than Evi) is no worse than your current reason for voting BB (you could see her eating HP). Is that to say that no one else would have done it?
This ongoing "obsession" about a first round vote that turned out to be meaningless is troubling ...
Maybe the dog only brings the ball back because he thinks you like throwing it.
ok guys i'm back. sorry I couldn't get on till this morning. And Spider is still on my radar but looking over the rounds I think it's strange out slamming is STILL reacting to a round 1 vote that has been over and done with. Why so upset over someone trying to save someone that they have played with many times before over someone they don't know a whole lot about.
With that said and Spider still on my radar for sure I'm going to change my vot to slamm....
p.s. my uncle is doing better they are talking pace maker and thank you everyone for your kind words. He has been moved out of the ICU
Things are not always as they appear
With that said and Spider still on my radar for sure I'm going to change my vot to slamm....
p.s. my uncle is doing better they are talking pace maker and thank you everyone for your kind words. He has been moved out of the ICU
Things are not always as they appear
i'm in a bit of a hurry but i don't prefer one of the 2 majorities over the other, so i'll leave my vote on koin for now, will hopefully be back before the end of the round
It's when you draw it you realize what it really looks like
It's when you draw it you realize what it really looks like
The koin vote is tempting, let me get my deb on, this will be a slow process since on phone
Bbgirl ---- I only have human experience with her iirc, I don't see why she would be so aggressive with a "zany" theory right out of the gate, there's not much upsid_e to it, will likely vote to protect her this round
Celt ----- again, Celt just makes it painfully obvious sometimes, could be wrong of course, but a no show Celt is a no wolf Celt ;)
Evi --- I'll cop to having fears that I'll be made the fool again , but that's not a logical reason to act either way. The harry eating again helps her for now
Cccgirl ---- still mulling over masonis command, probly worth ignoring though, off the table for this round
Deb ---- I have no reason not to suspect deb, but for right now I dont
Koin ---- leaning wolf but I don't know if I have the stones to follow through on it, feels like a leap of faith...but there are a 3 wolves playing, and there seems like one of the wolves must be playing actively
Habs ---- still a suspect but can't justify shooting yet
Slamm ----- letting herself get too emotionally invested, would kbow I'm human so risks looking foolish if she acted this way knowing my id, I would say human
Xxx ---- difficult to say, the crowd is saying human, I'll bite for now
Lawlor --- on my debs backburner
---This message was edited on 2014-12-09 09:37:39---
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
Bbgirl ---- I only have human experience with her iirc, I don't see why she would be so aggressive with a "zany" theory right out of the gate, there's not much upsid_e to it, will likely vote to protect her this round
Celt ----- again, Celt just makes it painfully obvious sometimes, could be wrong of course, but a no show Celt is a no wolf Celt ;)
Evi --- I'll cop to having fears that I'll be made the fool again , but that's not a logical reason to act either way. The harry eating again helps her for now
Cccgirl ---- still mulling over masonis command, probly worth ignoring though, off the table for this round
Deb ---- I have no reason not to suspect deb, but for right now I dont
Koin ---- leaning wolf but I don't know if I have the stones to follow through on it, feels like a leap of faith...but there are a 3 wolves playing, and there seems like one of the wolves must be playing actively
Habs ---- still a suspect but can't justify shooting yet
Slamm ----- letting herself get too emotionally invested, would kbow I'm human so risks looking foolish if she acted this way knowing my id, I would say human
Xxx ---- difficult to say, the crowd is saying human, I'll bite for now
Lawlor --- on my debs backburner
---This message was edited on 2014-12-09 09:37:39---
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
don't worry spider i don't play the same trick twice in a row, especially not if it works
It's when you draw it you realize what it really looks like
It's when you draw it you realize what it really looks like
Gonna vote koin, just sort of a prayer at this point, but better than bb and Slamm imo
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
The_Spider wrote:
I don't think I've ever played with her as a wolf before either and her theory was a bit out there wasn't it?
But looking at the game scores - this is only her 5th game of WWG so I think we need to cut her a bit of slack as she is likely still not completely sure what she is dong and most of the rest of us have 50+ games under our belts. IT could be intimidating.
I don't know the wolves are, nor do I feel strongly about any one being a wolf aside from Slamm. I do however feel that Spider is human as well as Deb. I agree with Dan that Celt is likely human as well.
Softy I am not sure about but getting mild vibes from her
Evi - could go either way
I am still sticking with Slamm as my most viable suspect.
Maybe the dog only brings the ball back because he thinks you like throwing it.
Bbgirl ---- I only have human experience with her iirc, I don't see why she would be so aggressive with a "zany" theory right out of the gate, there's not much upsid_e to it, will likely vote to protect her this round
I don't think I've ever played with her as a wolf before either and her theory was a bit out there wasn't it?
But looking at the game scores - this is only her 5th game of WWG so I think we need to cut her a bit of slack as she is likely still not completely sure what she is dong and most of the rest of us have 50+ games under our belts. IT could be intimidating.
I don't know the wolves are, nor do I feel strongly about any one being a wolf aside from Slamm. I do however feel that Spider is human as well as Deb. I agree with Dan that Celt is likely human as well.
Softy I am not sure about but getting mild vibes from her
Evi - could go either way
I am still sticking with Slamm as my most viable suspect.
Maybe the dog only brings the ball back because he thinks you like throwing it.
I wasn't trying to be critical, and her inexperience with us is all the more reason for a wolf bbgirl to be more reserved about those kind of theories, unless she is just naturally a very bold person (in a wwg sense at least haha
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
As far as being aggressive with a theory, you are right in your most recent post. I'm a very bold person period. I just say what's on my mind. up until then I had no theories or suspicions and that was my only one. I knew there was a posibilitythe round would end before I got back on so I just tried to throw it out there
Edit to add: although I did agree that I am very bold and just wanted to get it out there, I am not a wold lol. I am very much human!! ha ha
The_Spider voted for koin_era345
Evita voted for koin_era345
HABS2933 voted for slammngirl92
bbgrl voted for slammngirl92
koin_era345 voted for bbgrl
slammngirl92 voted for bbgrl
debc1 voted for Lawlor88
cccgirl
celtichero
Lawlor88
xxsoftballxx13x
have still not voted
---This message was edited on 2014-12-09 10:02:01---
Things are not always as they appear
Edit to add: although I did agree that I am very bold and just wanted to get it out there, I am not a wold lol. I am very much human!! ha ha
The_Spider voted for koin_era345
Evita voted for koin_era345
HABS2933 voted for slammngirl92
bbgrl voted for slammngirl92
koin_era345 voted for bbgrl
slammngirl92 voted for bbgrl
debc1 voted for Lawlor88
cccgirl
celtichero
Lawlor88
xxsoftballxx13x
have still not voted
---This message was edited on 2014-12-09 10:02:01---
Things are not always as they appear
The_Spider wrote:
I didn't mean to suggest that you were being critical, if it came across that way, I apologise.
I just think we need to give a bit of leeway to the less experienced players and let them make a few mistakes while pointing them out but not necessary reading much into what the behaviour could mean.
I don't think i've played with her more than once or twice so have no real sense of what her style may be.
Since no one else seems to agree with my vote on Slamm I could be persuaded to go along with the Koin vote.
There is still about half an hour left in the round. I will be back just before it ends to make a final decision. I don't like leaving it to a coin toss after the first round or two. The flip always turns out te wrong way for me! lol
Maybe the dog only brings the ball back because he thinks you like throwing it.
I wasn't trying to be critical,
I didn't mean to suggest that you were being critical, if it came across that way, I apologise.
I just think we need to give a bit of leeway to the less experienced players and let them make a few mistakes while pointing them out but not necessary reading much into what the behaviour could mean.
I don't think i've played with her more than once or twice so have no real sense of what her style may be.
Since no one else seems to agree with my vote on Slamm I could be persuaded to go along with the Koin vote.
There is still about half an hour left in the round. I will be back just before it ends to make a final decision. I don't like leaving it to a coin toss after the first round or two. The flip always turns out te wrong way for me! lol
Maybe the dog only brings the ball back because he thinks you like throwing it.
There's a few "spectators" around who arnt posting...yet...eager to see what if anything they do, if they do nothing, and we are looking at 3 humans in the tie, they areally very likely wolves (maybe goes without saying lol)
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
Well, I made it before round's end...and TMI, but it's a royal snotfest at my place right now. BF gave me the mother of all colds. Yuck.
Ok, back to the game...
Spider, I'm going to politely ask that you lay off Slammngrl. I've been reading through, and I may not agree with all of her points, but you do come across as being cold and mean to her. Of course, you can do as you wish, but to me it feels like being picked on - and obviously I've been in that situation recently (with mitigating RL factors clouding my judgment, but still). I'm not asking for a change of vote or opinion, just a change of tone.
Also, the game counter isn't always right. It says I have a score of 1, but my score was well over 50 when I stopped playing a couple of years ago, so at some point it reset.
Now, re the voting....we have a 3 way tie, and I'm not sure I'm comfortable voting any of them. I think slammn is human based on her reactions (though I could be wrong). I was more suspicious of BB earlier, but not sure now. And koin I'm suspicious of, but again not nearly as much as earlier.
To be honest, I'm really starting to suspect Deb who never explained her Lawlor vote. But I'm wondering if a vote for her is throwing my vote away so late in the round. I think I'm going to go ahead with the Lawlor vote because he's not exactly clear (I suspected them equally), but if he's human, and if I don't make it through the night, I would ask that people vote Deb for sure.
Ok, back to the game...
Spider, I'm going to politely ask that you lay off Slammngrl. I've been reading through, and I may not agree with all of her points, but you do come across as being cold and mean to her. Of course, you can do as you wish, but to me it feels like being picked on - and obviously I've been in that situation recently (with mitigating RL factors clouding my judgment, but still). I'm not asking for a change of vote or opinion, just a change of tone.
Also, the game counter isn't always right. It says I have a score of 1, but my score was well over 50 when I stopped playing a couple of years ago, so at some point it reset.
Now, re the voting....we have a 3 way tie, and I'm not sure I'm comfortable voting any of them. I think slammn is human based on her reactions (though I could be wrong). I was more suspicious of BB earlier, but not sure now. And koin I'm suspicious of, but again not nearly as much as earlier.
To be honest, I'm really starting to suspect Deb who never explained her Lawlor vote. But I'm wondering if a vote for her is throwing my vote away so late in the round. I think I'm going to go ahead with the Lawlor vote because he's not exactly clear (I suspected them equally), but if he's human, and if I don't make it through the night, I would ask that people vote Deb for sure.
If lawlor doesn't post I will vote to shoot him.....softball also came on and off....
Tick tock lawsy
Voted lawlor
---This message was edited on 2014-12-09 10:52:31---
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
Tick tock lawsy
Voted lawlor
---This message was edited on 2014-12-09 10:52:31---
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
Round end is so exciting...usually not on for it
---This message was edited on 2014-12-09 10:53:28---
---This message was edited on 2014-12-09 10:53:28---
You cannot post messages in previous rounds.
Follow Braingle!